The Recording Academy’s video game soundtrack award has been making waves in recent years, celebrating some of the most innovative and captivating scores in the industry. But a candid revelation from an indie developer has left many questioning the Academy’s approach to interactive music. RJ Lake, writer and director of Unbeatable, recently shared on social media that the Grammy Awards explicitly told them their mostly-vocal soundtrack wasn’t a good fit for the category.
This news comes as the nominations for the 2023 Grammys have been announced, showcasing an impressive lineup of video game soundtracks. The list includes some expected names like Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora – From the Ashes and Ghost of Yōtei, but what’s striking is that all these nominees feature predominantly instrumental music. One possible exception is 007 First Light, which features a Lana Del Rey song in its opening credits, but it’s unclear if this was taken into account during the nomination process.
RJ Lake’s experience sheds light on the Academy’s implicit preference for instrumental soundtracks. In a Bluesky post, he shared that D-Cell received an email from the Grammys stating that vocal songs aren’t what the voting judges are looking for in this category. This guidance was offered after they submitted their consideration form, but it wasn’t explicitly stated as a hard and fast rule anywhere in the awards description.
Lake’s comments have sparked debate among developers and music enthusiasts alike, with some arguing that this bias is puzzling given the significance of vocal songs in many video game soundtracks. The fact that Lake’s game, Unbeatable, features mostly-vocal tracks originally written for the game only adds to the controversy. This raises questions about the Academy’s definition of “interactive media” and whether it’s fair to exclude music with vocals from consideration.
The implications of this revelation go beyond the Grammys themselves. It highlights a broader issue in the industry: the perceived value placed on instrumental scores versus vocal-driven soundtracks. While some developers have managed to navigate this landscape by creating more traditional, orchestral-based scores, others like D-Cell are left wondering if their unique approach will ever be recognized.
As the gaming industry continues to evolve and push boundaries, it’s essential that award ceremonies like the Grammys adapt and reflect these changes. The revelation from RJ Lake serves as a reminder that the industry’s priorities should be centered around celebrating innovative and artistic expressions of music in games, regardless of their format or style.
The 69th Annual Grammy Awards will take place on February 7, 2027, with the video game soundtrack award presented earlier in the evening. It remains to be seen whether this year’s nominees will continue to favor instrumental scores or if we’ll see a shift towards more inclusive and diverse recognition of interactive music. One thing is certain: RJ Lake’s comments have opened up an important conversation about the role of vocal songs in video game soundtracks, and it’s up to the industry to decide what kind of music gets celebrated at its most prestigious awards.
Source: Game Developer XR — 2026-11-17